Custard Pie Recipes

Recipe Has a Photo

Serves/Makes: 8 Cook Time: 1-2 hrs Difficulty: 3/5
Ingredients: C Sugar, Ts Flour, Ts Salt, Eggs, C Milk

Serves/Makes: 3 Cook Time: 1-2 hrs Difficulty: 3/5
Ingredients: maple syrup, egg, egg white, fat-free milk, sugar

Blue Ribbon Custard Pie recipe rating (1 reviews)

Serves/Makes: 8 Cook Time: 30-60 minutes Difficulty: 3/5
Ingredients: eggs, slightly beaten, salt, sugar, milk, scalded, vanilla

Butternut Custard Pie Recipe

Serves/Makes: 8 Cook Time: 1-2 hrs Difficulty: 3/5
Ingredients: eggs, beaten, cooked and mashed butternut squash, half-and-half, dark corn syrup, packed brown sugar

Butterscotch Custard Pie Recipe

Butterscotch Custard Pie recipe rating (1 reviews)

Serves/Makes: 8 Cook Time: 1-2 hrs Difficulty: 3/5
Ingredients: pastry for single crust pie (deep dish if using store bought), eggs, (18 oz. size) evaporated/canned milk, packed brown sugar, whipped cream, optional

Buttery Lemon Custard Pie Recipe

Serves/Makes: 10 Cook Time: 1-2 hrs Difficulty: 3/5
Ingredients: ***Crust***, sheets phyllo dough, thawed if frozen, butter, melted, ***Filling***, fresh lemon juice

Canadian Coconut Custard Pie Recipe

Serves/Makes: 10 Cook Time: 1-2 hrs Difficulty: 3/5
Ingredients: (15-ounce size) all-ready pie crusts, eggs, separated, milk, granulated sugar, (15-ounce size) cream of coconut

Caramel Custard Pie Recipe

Serves/Makes: 4 Cook Time: 30-60 minutes Difficulty: 2/5
Ingredients: milk, melted butter, eggs, vanilla extract, brown sugar, firmly packed

Custard Pecan Pie Recipe

Serves/Makes: 8 Cook Time: 30-60 minutes Difficulty: 3/5
Ingredients: chopped pecans, toasted, milk, cornstarch, sugar, vanilla extract

Egg Custard Pie Recipe

Serves/Makes: 10 Cook Time: 30-60 minutes Difficulty: 3/5
Ingredients: eggs, slightly beaten, vanilla, salt, nutmeg, sugar

Egg Custard Pie Recipe

Serves/Makes: 2 pies Cook Time: 1-2 hrs Difficulty: 3/5
Ingredients: deep dish pie shells (9 inch), ground nutmeg, milk, (12 ounce) evaporated milk, eggs

Egg Custard Pie II Recipe

Serves/Makes: 8 Cook Time: 30-60 minutes Difficulty: 3/5
Ingredients: nine inch unbaked pie shell, granulated sugar, flour, ground nutmeg, table salt

Grandma Mary's Custard Pie Recipe

Serves/Makes: 8 Cook Time: 30-60 minutes Difficulty: 2/5
Ingredients: milk, marshmallows, eggs, beaten, sugar, salt

Lemon & Coconut Custard Pie Recipe

Serves/Makes: 8 Cook Time: 2-5 hrs Difficulty: 3/5
Ingredients: unbaked 9-inch pie crust with a 3/8-inch rim, chilled, eggs, orange marmalade, lemon juice, cornstarch

Mango Custard Pie Recipe

Serves/Makes: 8 Cook Time: 30-60 minutes Difficulty: 2/5
Ingredients: brown sugar, packed, salt, cinnamon, nutmeg, mashed or pureed mango

Old Fashioned Egg Custard Pie Recipe

Serves/Makes: 8 Cook Time: 30-60 minutes Difficulty: 3/5
Ingredients: butter, softened, sugar, eggs, flour, evaporated milk

Perfect Custard Pie Recipe

Serves/Makes: 6 Cook Time: 30-60 minutes Difficulty: 3/5
Ingredients: (9") baked pie shell, eggs, sugar, salt, nutmeg

Praline Custard Pie Recipe

Serves/Makes: 10 Cook Time: 1-2 hrs Difficulty: 3/5
Ingredients: packed light brown sugar, chopped pecans, butter, PLUS, butter, divided, baked pie shell (9-inch size)

Southern Custard Chess Pie Recipe

Serves/Makes: 8 Cook Time: 30-60 minutes Difficulty: 3/5
Ingredients: eggs -- beaten well, brown sugar, granulated sugar, flour, stick butter or margarine

Squash Custard Pie Recipe

Serves/Makes: 8 Cook Time: 2-5 hrs Difficulty: 3/5
Ingredients: eggs, cooked, pureed butternut squash, corn starch, pumpkin pie spice, salt

Squoconut Custard Pie Recipe

Serves/Makes: 8 Cook Time: 2-5 hrs Difficulty: 3/5
Ingredients: all-purpose unbleached flour, evaporated milk, half-and-half, sugar, eggs, lightly beaten

The Impossible Pie Recipe

Serves/Makes: 6 Cook Time: < 30 minutes Difficulty: 2/5
Ingredients: baking mix, sugar, eggs, milk, coconut

Unusual Custard Pie Recipe

Serves/Makes: 8 Cook Time: 30-60 minutes Difficulty: 2/5
Ingredients: flour, milk, eggs, sugar, vanilla