melanie REVIEW: I did not add the water as the other reviewers did and it was great! I left out the 1 ounce unsweetened chocolate since I didn't have any. I also used walnuts instead of pecans. Was done in exactly 50 minutes at 350 and was delicious!!
Apr 8, 2009
cindersgirl Member since: April 8, 2009 REVIEW: I made this without using the other ingredients listed on the cake box. It got rave reviews from my husband's workplace and my husband ate THREE pieces. I think you might think that the thickness of the mixture won't come out right, but I made it EXACTLY the way the recipe read and it came out great. Did you guys actually make the cake??
Apr 8, 2009
cindersgirl Member since: April 8, 2009 COMMENT: Continued from last review: I was asked by 8 different people for this recipe. I'm sure you don't add items from the cake box instructions.
Sep 9, 2008
love2bake REVIEW: I made it without an extra cup of water and it also turned out great (the batter will be pretty thick). The cake is delicious and moist and rich enough that it doesn't need frosting. A sprinkle of powdered sugar is just the right touch.
Dec 11, 2007
Guest Foodie COMMENT: I have a similar recipe to this, and you are supposed to add the ingredients listed on the cake mix box, such as the eggs, in addition to the recipe itself. I wonder if that would work for this one as well.
Oct 17, 2007
Guest Foodie REVIEW: I should have read review no. 1 - what a waste of money and time. No eggs. It fell flat and was a gooey mess.
Jun 17, 2007
girlienerd Member since: June 17, 2007 REVIEW: I believe an ingredient was omitted from this recipe: 1 cup water.
The batter did not look right, so I added the cup of water and the cake turned out DELIGHTFUL!! Also, I used German chocolate instead of semi-sweet, but I think either would have done nicely.
Anyway, I highly recommend this one for a party or potluck, as I have gotten nothing but rave reviews each time I make it. Thanks!
May 17, 2006
DC Baker REVIEW: Umm..this cake doesn't have eggs. I thought that seemed strange and against my better judgement I tried it anyway...it's a wet mess and a waste of ingredients...guess my office won't be getting a cake tomorrow. I think the person who posted this made a huge mistake. Boo.