Valerie's Review REVIEW: November 21, 2013 Well, all the other reviews about how awesome this soup recipe is aren't wrong! It's incredible, actually. Quite possibly the best potato soup I've ever had (and I've tried a lot!) The crock pot gets the potatoes very tender and it has great flavor. Rich and filling. I loved everything about it!
Guest Foodie January 21, 2015 REVIEW:
This one gets raves from all. I have served this at Super Bowl parties as well as a cold weekend comfort meal and everyones loves it. Thanks.
Alicia December 8, 2014 REVIEW:
I absolutely love this soup! It's my go-to recipe and everyone loves it. I use onion powder and garlic powder in place of actual veggies and I love how creamy it is! Love to stir in sour cream right into the soup to give it a delightful tang. Just wonderful.
Member since: Apr 5, 2003
queenforaday November 10, 2014 REVIEW:
Really loved this soup. Cooked on low for 5 hours and it was done though.
Member since: Feb 11, 2001
smurf October 24, 2014 REVIEW:
This ended up being one of the best soups I've ever made!
Cyndi_RN2405 October 5, 2014 REVIEW:
My fiance and I absolutely LOVED this soup! It is perfect for a cold winter day and was very filling. I just made a couple modifications to it. I used 6 large red potatoes (Yes they take forever to cut up 6 of them, but totally worth it!!), corn and finely chopped carrots, and just kind of estimated by adding a little more until it looked like enough in the soup. I also added sour cream (probably about 1/4 to 2/3 a cup, just estimated here too) when I added the half & half, and a half cup of extra sharp cheddar cheese. Then I let it cook on high for about another hour to make sure it was a nice and somewhat thick consistency. I also used less onion based on the reviews people had written, and I think the flavor turned out great! My fiance kept commenting about how he was so excited to have leftovers for tomorrow, this is definitely going down in the "favorites" recipe book!!
gitte September 23, 2014 REVIEW:
It is very delicious, but just a little too salty. I would recommend one and a half teaspoons of salt instaed of two and a half.
Stephanie September 15, 2014 REVIEW:
By far the best potato soup I've ever made. I found this recipe last winter, and it quickly became a regular menu item in our house. My kids are huge fans!
Member since: Aug 11, 2001
frgs19 September 14, 2014 REVIEW:
This is such an easy but delicious soup! We absolutely loved it and will definitely make it again. Thank you for this recipe!
Member since: Jan 21, 2002
NOLAgal August 22, 2014 REVIEW:
Couldn't believe how addicting this soup was. I expected to have leftovers because I made a full recipe but three of us inhaled it all and didn't touch the rest of our food!
VaBeachDad July 29, 2014 REVIEW:
So easy, family loved it. Big hit!
Jane April 13, 2014 REVIEW:
This was the best soup I have ever made!!! It was very easy also. I only used half an onion and 1 clove of garlic; it was perfect for us this way. I will definitely make this soup often!!
Member since: Feb 25, 2014
solamentenic February 25, 2014 REVIEW:
This was a really good recipe. I did cut down on the potatoes from 6 to 4. I also cut down on the onion to half and the garlic cloves to two. I also added a little bit of the bacon grease and some Frank's Hot Sauce and it gave it a nice little kick.
New Fan February 16, 2014 REVIEW:
hands down the best potato soup i've ever had! Thank you so much for sharing this recipe! It's a new favorite here with us! I made it exactly as written and we loved it. It is a bit garlicky but we liked that a LOT!
Angela February 12, 2014 REVIEW:
This soup is incredible! I did use a small onion, not large (large is kinda relative so an actual measurement would be helpful). I did use three cloves of garlic but again that is one of those measurements that's not helpful. I used three small cloves and it was delicious. It's a rich soup so as much as I'd love to eat this every day, I'll have to save it as a treat. Although we're about to be snowed in so I'll probably make it as comfort food again!! Thank you for the recipe!
Denise February 1, 2014 REVIEW:
Way too much garlic...overpowering...next time no garlic and small onion. Loved the consistency of the soup though.
KT January 26, 2014 REVIEW:
Making this soup for the third time - it's outstanding!!!
Sandra January 25, 2014 REVIEW:
Amazing recipe!! OMG! We ate every drop. I only used a small onion (would be nice if it gave measurement in cups instead of just size) and it worked out great. Everyone in my family loved this recipe and that's rare. Best potato soup I think I've ever had! Thank you for sharing this recipe, it's going in my permanent rotation this winter!
Soup lover January 25, 2014 REVIEW:
The garlic and onion was overpowering. Too much! Won't be making this one again
Sarah January 11, 2014 REVIEW:
The idea of this soup is good, but it is way, WAY too salty. Also, I only added about half the onion suggested (if that), and the flavor was pretty overpowering. All in all, not bad, but I probably won't use this recipe again.
luvsdogs January 10, 2014 REVIEW:
Heaven in a bowl! This is by far the best potato soup I've ever had.
Kc January 8, 2014 COMMENT: does anyone know how many calories are in one serving??
CDKitchen Staff Reply: The calorie and nutritional breakdown per serving is listed in the "nutrition" section of the recipe (under the "more recipes like this" section above)
tlg January 5, 2014 REVIEW:
It was pretty good, but next time I'm only putting a very small onion in it. Otherwise it was great.
Member since: Dec 26, 2013
olga1224 December 26, 2013 REVIEW:
Love this potato soup recipe. Easy and taste delicious.
Member since: Mar 8, 2002
shellyann2 December 21, 2013 REVIEW:
This is our favorite soup
Guest Foodie December 12, 2013 REVIEW:
What a great soup! I love how simple the recipe is too. VERY filling though so keep that in mind if you are serving other food with it.
Ellyn December 11, 2013 REVIEW:
This is the best potato soup ever!!! I have made this for many family members and parties and it is always a hit. I put all ingredients, including cheese, sour cream, and bacon before serving. If you want the soup thicker boil a few potatoes and mash to use as a thickner.
asnyderbuckeye December 7, 2013 REVIEW:
I made this tonight and everyone loved it! I used dehydrated garlic, half an onion and chicken stock. Has a nice consistency, it's thick and creamy with flavor. Our guests commented that you don't even have to put salt on it, has lots of flavor. The bacon makes it! Baked it to crispy and crumbled on top with cheese and sour cream. Did not use the chives, was oniony enough already.
ojoy November 22, 2013 COMMENT: Sounds good, but WAY, WAY, WAY to much salt!!
That's a full day's worth in one serving.
Will try it with 1/3 the salt.
Dewana November 15, 2013 REVIEW:
This is my first time making any potato soup. It is super easy and super delicious. I am making it for my parents tomorrow. This soup is seriously flawless :-)
Anna November 12, 2013 REVIEW:
This soup was delicious! I made it exactly as written except used 1/2 cheddar and 1/2 cheddar Jack cheese because that's all I had. The consistency was perfect. A great recipe to have waiting ready to eat on a cold raw day.
Sarah November 8, 2013 REVIEW:
Chose this for my first time making loaded baked potato soup. Turned out DELICIOUS and I will definitely be adding this recipe to my stash. I about one and a half batches (had a bunch of small potatoes that needed to be used up). I chopped the bacon and cooked it with the potatoes the whole time, and I left the skin on the potatoes. Only thing I HAD to change was that I added some flour to thicken it up. Yum yum, FIVE STARS!
Member since: Aug 11, 2002
gsara November 4, 2013 REVIEW:
This is the most used recipe in my crock pot! The kids request it almost weekly now. We love it! I've tried a few variations on this recipe (adding in veggies, other seasonings, etc) but this is my favorite version.
Member since: Jan 21, 2002
tootsieroll October 16, 2013 REVIEW:
I've made this a dozen times now and every time it turns out great. Very delicious!
Member since: Sep 6, 2001
souplover October 8, 2013 REVIEW:
This soup is serious comfort food. I was having a bad week so I put this in the crock this morning knowing I wouldn't feel like cooking tonight and came home to the most wonderful soup. Instantly put me in a good mood again. Delicious!
Lindsay Reese October 6, 2013 REVIEW:
Made this today. My kids couldn't get enough. I liked that the ingredients were simple. I will definitely make this again and again. Thank you.
Katie L September 22, 2013 REVIEW:
Really great! Added broccoli to the soup. Worked out nicely.
GSLeader September 16, 2013 REVIEW:
Very good soup. I used my fat-free half and half. I didn't have onion or fresh chives or garlic cloves. I substituted using 1 1/2 TBL onion powder, 3 tsp dried chives, and 1 1/2 tsp of minced garlic. I found the substitution amounts on the internet. I also used bacon bits. All good. A little quicker since I had less chopping. I will only use a little less pepper since we aren't big on pepper. Will definitely make again.
Guest Foodie August 31, 2013 REVIEW:
Great and easy soup to make! However, it was a little runny so I added about 1/4 a cup of flour and it was perfect!!!! Highly recommend!
koko July 25, 2013 REVIEW:
I love the loaded potato soup you can get at some restaurants but I had never made it at home. Tried this recipe yesterday and my super picky husband who claims he doesn't like potato soups loved it and ate seconds. I'm not sure what sets it apart from other recipes other than maybe the long cooking time in the crock pot either improves the texture or flavor but he loved it and we now have a new favorite soup recipe to make!
Katie July 20, 2013 REVIEW:
This soup was delicious. I actually converted it to a stove top recipe and it turned out fantastic! My picky sister absolutely loved it. I am making it for the second time this week tonight! This is a fantastic recipe for summer or winter and it is sure to satisfy everyone. Note: I did sub. heavy cream with a mixture of greek yogurt and milk, and also I did not have any chives or onions, but it still turned out great! Two thumbs up.
Member since: Apr 14, 2013
sugarcain April 14, 2013 REVIEW:
This is so fantastically simple to make. I did adjust the seasonings to my personal preference and sauteed the onion before adding. I also added dried chives to the broth and the sour cream to the soup about an hour before serving. Oh yes, it also got a dollop of it on top in my bowl. But I love me some sour cream. This was de-freaking-licious! I wrote this review and gave it 5 stars because it was a great soup base recipe. But then again, I never follow recipes exactly. I have really picky eaters in my house.
Member since: Feb 22, 2008
thisgurlluvs2cook March 8, 2013 REVIEW:
We are in the throes of a kitchen remodel, meaning I have no stove or oven. So I am trying desperately to find good crock pot recipes because my husband and I are dying for a home cooked meal! I had a bunch of potatos and onion to use up so I decided to make potato soup. The day is cold and rainy, so perfect soup weather. I followed the recipe exactly and it came out perfect! Great taste and easy to make. My husband loved it, too. Makes a lot of soup so we will have leftovers for awhile! Which is great because that means all I have to do is heat this up in the microwave and dinner or lunch, is served!
ColoradoMom March 7, 2013 REVIEW:
I cannot find the words to tell you how good this was! The soup had the perfect seasoning, consistency, and texture. My kids LOVED it. So easy to make and its tastes better than any restaurant soup I've ever had. Thank you so much!!!!!
DOTJOAN January 31, 2013 REVIEW:
I never made loaded potato soup before because I can not tolerate creamy soups. But it is my neighbor's favorite. She loved it and so did my husband. My husband is a very fussy eater. It was a great recipe without making any changes. I will probably make it again before the winter ends.
brianne January 31, 2013 REVIEW:
I'm currently stuffing my face with the soup that I just made...it's awesome! Very simple recipe but SO GOOD! I will definitely be making this all the time in the future.
Tiki Torch January 30, 2013 REVIEW:
I made this for a potluck at work and it was a hit. The only changes I made were I used Lipton Onion Soup mix in place of the onion and cut the salt to half what it had suggested. I also mixed in the sour cream with about an hour to go. (all suggestions from other reviewers) The only thing I might change next time is omitting the extra salt completely. With the extra salt from the soup mix, it was just a little too salty for my preference but overall it was fabulous.
bugg January 28, 2013 REVIEW:
Made this soup with A LOT less salt. The 2 1/2 tsp. called for scared me a bit, so I backed off a bit. It was perfect. My kids love it almost as much as my stovetop baked potato soup.
Did anyone make the soup exactly as the recipe states? Was the 2 1/2 tsp salt too much or just right?
swilson215 November 17, 2012 REVIEW:
I wish I could give it 4.5. The only change I made from the recipe was to use a bag of hashed browns (I used the Ore Ida 32 oz bag) instead of peeling and chopping potatoes. Texture turned out almost perfect. I wish I would have had maybe one more potato in it, but it was fine. My main gripe: I love onion, but a WHOLE chopped onion was just way too much. I wish I would have halved it. It was more like an onion and baked potato soup. But it was still tasty, and what a great starting recipe. I added the half-and-half and the sour cream at hour 4 (on high) and let it cook another 30 minutes. Turned out delicious (if a bit onion-y) and I would definitely make it again (with half as much onion).
Bittytooch November 15, 2012 REVIEW:
This recipe was fantastic prepared just the way it way presented. For the life of me, I do not understand why people alter a recipe then rate it. It is not a true rating of the recipe if you go changing everything with an "I did this..." Again, delicious just the way it was written.
cj13 November 9, 2012 REVIEW:
This recipe TASTE GREAT!! Followed the recipe except i add about 1/4 cup of sour cream alond with the 1 cup of half and half.
DoggoMom November 8, 2012 REVIEW:
This took FOREVER...maybe too many potatoes. When it all came together, it was SO worth the effort. I ate two bowls, before the potatoes were cooked. The "I'm not hungry," person in the house, LOVED it. Will definitely make it, earlier, again. FIVE STARS.
Member since: Oct 31, 2012
uniwendy October 31, 2012 REVIEW:
I made this soup for a pot luck and it was a hit! Several people asked for the recipe. I did make a few modifications that I learned from other reviewers. I added the sour cream during the cooking and substituted Lipton onion soup in the place of the onion because I didn't want to cut up onions in the morning :-)
I highly recommend this soup for anyone who loves baked potato soup!
Yvette October 7, 2012 REVIEW:
Can't. Stop. Eating! THis is the best!
Guest Foodie September 30, 2012 COMMENT: This has always been my fav, want to add a even better touch add Famous Daves seasoning to the whole pot just a few dashes and Wow!...
Guest July 26, 2012 COMMENT: Am making this delicious potato soup for a crowd. Made it last week and my grand kids and husband loved. Does anyone know how long it will keep in the refrigerator. I kept it for 5 days and it was still very good. I would like to make it today to be eaten next week.
albrit1 February 21, 2012 REVIEW:
I tried the soup and it was good. I read all the reviews first and adjusted the salt and garlic. I sub the potatoes for hash browns and it was good...I used a half bag and should have used the whole bag. I used green onion instead of chives....next time I will use the chives and a whole bag of hash browns. I will make it again.
Sherry February 2, 2012 COMMENT: To thicken this potato soup just add a tablespoon or more of instant potatoes. Works great
nat December 18, 2011 COMMENT: This receipe was NOT good! I was shocked when I read it wanted a large onion but I just followed as instructed and yuck! tasted like french onion soup and was just not good at all. It might have potential with 1/4 cup of onions but I should have followed my instincts so shame on me. Good luck.
Annabo October 27, 2011 REVIEW:
Made this soup to celebrate the first snow of the season and it was delicious!! I let the onions sweat over low heat before throwing them in and added celery as well. I substituted the sour cream and the cream/half & half for 0% Greek Yogurt to save some calories and it was delicious!! It gave the soup a nice tangy flavor and made it very creamy! I also added the bacon, yogurt (or sour cream and 1/2 & 1/2), and cheddar about an hour before serving.
Grated in some fresh nutmeg at the end and it was perfect! Thanks for the recipe, this potato soup recipe is our favorite so far!
CWash October 26, 2011 REVIEW:
We subbed the potatoes for frozen hashbrowns, eliminated onions because of preferences and used the sour cream. I love that it was ready quickly and we even had guests over to enjoy.
Dannica October 23, 2011 REVIEW:
This recipe is very good! I made a few changes based on other user comments, such as adding the sour cream right to the soup, and I also added the bacon pieces right into the soup instead of as a garnish. The only thing I did not like was the texture of the soup, as I found it to be TOO soupy, so I simply added two more potatoes that I quickly boiled before, and I was happy!
jasory October 22, 2011 REVIEW:
This soup is excellent! My daughters both loved it and I made it again recently for the picky eater one! We make bread in our breadmaker to enjoy with this one. Can't wait for a cold winters day to make it again, since its the kind of soup to enjoy on one of those days!
Guest Foodie October 20, 2011 REVIEW:
Fantastic! I used vegetable broth instead and added a little celery for flavor. It's my favorite recipe ever! I added the sour cream to the whole pot while cooking and used cream to thicken it. Thank you for sharing this!!!!!
grimmfam September 6, 2011 REVIEW:
Soo good but i would back off on the garlic a teaspoon or so its a lil powerful! But yum what a good recipe!
Guest Foodie March 30, 2011 REVIEW:
Easy and very delicious! I saved this one in my recipe book! I used all green onions instead of yellow or white and cut the number of potatoes in half (still plenty). I also added the half and half, cheese and sour cream about an hour before we ate it. Love it! Even my picky 13 year-old loved it!
Guest Foodie March 28, 2011 REVIEW:
Wow! Great recipe and very easy to make! My kind of recipe. Very tasty, and like the restaurant varieties. Could be a bit thicker. I sauteed the onions first as one reviewer suggested and added the sour cream to the whole pot of soup. Might use a little less salt next time, but overall...its a KEEPER!
Mom-engineer January 15, 2011 COMMENT: My toddlers love potato soup at restaurants, and I was hoping this would be one of their favorites! However, the soup has too much garlic, onion and salt! It left a bad aftertaste, and they definitely hated it! My husband didn't mind it that much, but thought it had too much salt. A teaspoon is way too much!
dmf January 12, 2011 REVIEW:
This recipe is phenomenal! Made it yesterday; there was some leftover--cannot wait to enjoy a bowl today!
TNDeb December 22, 2010 REVIEW:
I tried this recipe last weekend and it was DELICIOUS! Next time I will try the suggestion of adding the sour cream while cooking. Adding after I dished it out was yummy!!
Guest Foodie December 22, 2010 REVIEW:
Very tasty and adaptable. I think next time I'll add some broccoli. I do have one suggestion: saute the onions prior to cooking with the potatoes. We had one batch go down the drain after following the recipe. The raw onions created a very funky flavor in that first batch. I'm an onion lover but something didn't work the first time.
cookinmama December 15, 2010 REVIEW:
Absolutely delicious! AND super easy! Like some mentioned above I added the whole cup of sour cream to the entire soup rather than just on top. I absolutely hate sour cream, but to my delight I couldn't even taste it and it made the soup richer. I will definitely be making this again very soon!
Guest Foodie November 21, 2010 REVIEW:
This soup was awesome! It tastes just like my favorite loaded baked potato soup that I order at a local restaurant. I used green onions instead of chives and it was delicious! I made it to serve 4 people and it was enough for an average size bowl for 3 people so keep that in mind if you are making it for larger families.
kim November 17, 2010 REVIEW:
My family loves this so much, I make it for dinner at least once a week!
Guest Foodie February 18, 2010 REVIEW:
The suggestions listed above were great. I made my potatoes a little larger and smashed them with a large spoon. So I still had some large chunks. I also added the sour cream to the whole pot.This soup is great enjoy!!
Guest Foodie February 4, 2010 REVIEW:
I made this, but like one of the other reviews I added sour cream to the whole mix and left the potaoes solid and did not mash. It was FANTASTIC!!!! We put the lrft overs away and the next night I fixed meatloaf, the family begged for the soup on the side instead of mashed potatoes! Even better the second night!!!
Danielle November 21, 2009 REVIEW:
Very very tasty. I added three different flavors of cheese, and it is very good. Everyone loved it! Must try :)
Guest Foodie November 18, 2009 REVIEW:
I used turkey bacon and added it to the potatoes before cooking them. I also added dried chives and some basil to the potato mix. I opted not to use the sour cream.
It was delicious! my roommates loved it. Thanks for the recipe!
loriliz October 31, 2009 REVIEW:
I made this last sunday for my family, they loved it. I didn't have any bacon fried up so I used bacon bits instead, just as good! I didn't measure exactly but sure came out good, took the rest to work and the guys gobbled it up. True comfort food - easy and wonderful!
Member since: Sep 20, 2009
nuttygardener October 28, 2009 REVIEW:
The only thing I did different was to add the cup of sour cream to the whole of the soup, not just on each bowl. That thickened it enough that next time I won't lightly mash the potatoes. It is delicious and simple either way.