Connie REVIEW: Super easy to make and turned out great!
Oct 17, 2010
Guest Foodie REVIEW: So yummy and SO easy! Definitely one to keep on hand!
Dec 13, 2008
Guest Foodie COMMENT: Taste was good, directions not. Oh, also did what other reviewer did - subbed light for dark corn syrup - too much molasses flavor in dark for the delicate taste of caramel.
Given the bit I know about caramel, I stirred until it boiled, then didn't stir until soft ball. After I added the other ingredients (not the vanilla), I stirred again until boil, then occasionally. Stopping when it gets to a boil gives you light colored thick sugar. It's not caramel tasting at all. So, I left it boiling on med-low heat. I waited until soft ball again. By this time is was like a copper penny. It poured out well and is delicious. Difference is that this is much thicker than a topping...for the topping, you'd have to stop between a boil and 220 or 225. Going in to the 220's would give you more color and flavor, but still be thin enough to pour.
Sep 14, 2008
NiNi REVIEW: This tasted just like grandma's homemade caramel recipe with just evaporated milk and sugar. I actually omitted the Karo syrup part and it was just fine. I poured it over a homemade yellow sheet cake and the husband and kids loved it!
Dec 17, 2007
Guest Foodie REVIEW: This was quite easy - but, the recipe didn't say if you should or should not stir while it's coming to temperature. I quickly scanned some other caramel recipes and they said not to stir, so I did not.
I would make it next time with only 1/2 dark corn syrup and 1/2 light. The dark did impart a molasses flavor to it - I needed this for a specific function and the molasses flavor got in the way. I was able to add it to some dulce de leche I had so it ended up working perfectly.