BROWSE MOREfriendship bread & starter
non-bread machine
babka
french bread
gingerbread
oatmeal bread
coconut bread
wheat bread
amish
united states & canada
RECIPE TOOLS:
print
shopping list
email
save
add photo
mastercook
add review
rate recipe
show nutrition
mobile
puzzleSHARE:

Amish Friendship Bread Starter and Bread

5 stars based on 21 reviews
Ready in: Over 5 hrs ?
Difficulty: 4/5
Serves/Makes: 5 cups
INGREDIENTS:
***Starter***
1 tablespoon active dry yeast
2 cups warm water, (110 degrees F)
1 cup flour
1 cup sugar
1 cup milk
***To Make Bread***
1 cup vegetable oil
1 cup sugar
2 cups flour
3 eggs
1 small instant vanilla pudding mix
1 teaspoon cinnamon
1/2 teaspoon salt
1/2 teaspoon baking soda
1/4 teaspoon baking powder
1/2 cup milk
***Cinnamon Sugar***
1 cup sugar
2 tablespoons cinnamon
DIRECTIONS:
For Starter: Dissolve yeast in 1/2 cup of the warm water in a deep glass or plastic container. Stir in remaining warm water, flour and sugar.
Beat until smooth. Cover. (A large glass jar or bowl with a tight fitting lid works best for this, but a 1/2 gallon zip baggie can also be used).
Because your first batch of starter contains fresh yeast, you can skip the next set of directions and go directly to the instructions for splitting your start.
Do not refrigerate! Do not stir with a metal spoon! The starter requires 10 days for fermentation.
Day 1- Begin or receive starter Day 2- Stir with wooden spoon (or squish baggie) Day 3- Stir with wooden spoon (or squish baggie) Day 4- Stir with wooden spoon (or squish baggie) Day 5- Add 1 cup sugar, 1 cup flour, 1 cup milk Day 6- Stir with wooden spoon (or squish baggie) Day 7- Stir with wooden spoon (or squish baggie) Day 8- Do Nothing Day 9- Do Nothing Day 10- Add 1 cup sugar, 1 cup flour, 1 cup milk
Put 1 cup of starter in each of three containers. Give 2 away to friends and keep one. This will begin their Day 1.
For Bread: You will have about 1 cup of batter left (besides the 1 cup you have saved for yourself). To the remaining batter add vegetable oil, sugar, flour, baking powder, baking soda, eggs, milk, vanilla pudding mix, cinnamon, and salt. Beat until well blended. Add one cup raisins, chocolate chips or nuts, if desired.
Grease 2 loaf pans well, and sprinkle with cinnamon sugar, coating bottom well. Turn batter into pans, and sprinkle remaining cinnamon sugar onto tops of loaves. Bake at 325 degrees F for one hour.
NUTRITION:
This Amish Friendship Bread Starter and Bread recipe from CDKitchen serves/makes 5 cups
Recipe ID: 27161
REVIEWS:

Guest: MamaB 2010-04-26
I really love this recipe! I have been looking to find the starter for a while since I forgot about it in the pantry the last time. My family adores the bread that comes from this! for everyone asking if it'll be ok. No matter what you did it should be fine. this is very forgiving! I've baked it on the 13th day, I've forgotten to mix it. I've used a metal spoon. it was delicious every time so don't sweat it!

Guest: katiecathey 2009-12-24
I did add milk with starter and it made the five cups. It is really runny at firt but will thicken after sitting a couple of minutes.

Guest: teresab 2009-08-16
instead of using oil, I substitute applesauce, chunky applesause is even better!

Guest: bubbalou 2008-09-14
question: where's step 2? How do you start more with a starter? Add to the begining or what?
CDKitchen Note: Read the directions very carefully, they are a little confusing because of all the steps but I believe all the info is there.

Guest: Domestic Goddess 2008-09-05
The bread is GREAT!! Ony problem is now, all my friends, neighbors, ect. have the starter mix, and when I keep seperating them, I am getting too many mixes. How do I cut down on the amount of baggies since everyone already has as many as they want???

tulip3274 2007-11-11
This bread is simply awesome. I have kept it going for 4 months now, just because my kids and I love it so much. Some other add ins we love: Use 1 small box vanilla pudding, and two single serving cups of applesauce; use chocolate or cheesecake or banana pudding; leave out the pudding, and instead use 2 cups of mashed pumpkin or zucchini

Guest: mrs donor 2006-10-08
this was sooo much fun to let the kids participate. they were able to mash each day and add all the ingr. the bread tastes great too!!! we decided to add more cinn/sugar on top for a crunchy coating it tasted so good!! good luck have fun and share w/ your friends. the organ family

Guest: Anonymous 2006-03-20
That was so easy!! Thank you! Do this as a different and kind thing to do for your friends. TRY IT!

Guest: S 2010-08-10
For starter, I compared the recipe with other recipe from different sites and used only 1/4 warm warter + 1 cup of warm milk ( milk you add on the 6th & 10th day doesn't need to be warmed up). It turned out perfect, and I ended up having 5 cups of starter this way.

Guest: SE 2010-08-11
I used only 1/4 warm water instead of 2 cups, & added 1 cup warm milk. It turned out just fine. I ended up having 5 cups of starter on the 10th day. (Milk does not need to be warmed up on the 6th & 10th day) I also realized that I have used metal cups when I added flour & sugar without thinking much, but the bread was still good. Leaving the starter out for 10 days scared me at first, but it is like wine & smells a bit like so.

Guest: Anonymous 2009-04-30
Will it affect the Friendship Bread if you wait until the 11th day to make the Bread? Carolyn Major

Guest: KarlBob 2008-11-12
You can keep using the same starter for a long time because the yeast is alive. Whenever you add flour, sugar, etc. you are feeding the yeast, and it will reproduce. That's also the reason why the bags you give away don't need powdered yeast added to them. They're chock full of healthy, live yeast.

Guest: no Julia Child 2008-10-08
when do you put in the milk?? it doesn't say in the starter recipe??? can milk sit in your pantry for 10 days fermenting?? i'm confused.

Guest: carolinamamasita 2008-06-28
I had that concern also about the milk... is listed in the starter ingredients but not listed in the recipe to add it ... it says add remaining water , flour and sugar. I added the milk anyways ... and the looks runny ....??? Now according to the instructions there is no waiting time ? i can go to split it right now and make my loafs? I am confused ...so sorry ..
meal / dish
method
occasion
ingredient
cuisine
photo
recipEbox log in
log out
register (it's free!)
forgot password?
help/FAQ
