Guest Foodie REVIEW: I tried to give this recipe one star, but it would only let me give 5 stars. This recipe had too many steps, took too long, and resulted in biscuits with holes. As others said, there isn't enough flour in the recipe (or maybe it requires some kind of special donut technology to handle). A disappointing, overwrought waste of time and sourdough starter.
Jan 9, 2014
Karen Morris REVIEW: I had to add a lot of extra flour, probably because I had a wet starter. These doughnuts turned out excellent, however. I ended up forming them into twists rather than cutting them out in doughnut shapes. I think next time I'll try to use this as a beignet recipe, using half and half instead of milk, and cutting the dough into squares prior to the last rising. Thank you!!
Jan 5, 2014
KMorris COMMENT: I'm preparing the recipe now. I had to add a lot of extra flour during the kneading process because the dough was too wet to knead. I'm hoping my doughnuts won't turn out too heavy as a consequence. However, my sourdough starter is new, and it might have been a bit too moist. I'm planning to roll and cut out the doughnut dough this evening, allow it to rise overnight and then fry the doughnuts early in the morning.
Apr 7, 2012
CC REVIEW: Holy deliciousness! This is going to be my go to recipe for when I have a brunch and/or guests staying with us. This recipe really isn't that difficult, you just need to allow for the time which will vary from geographical areas due to the humidity etc. However, I have to say that the batter-like consistency was a little intimidating at first, but once you added the last of the flour before cutting and letting them rise for the last time, I knew that these would be worth all the time and effort I put into it! We dyed Easter eggs and made cookies waiting for the dough to make its first rise. I set them out overnight for the last rise after shaping them and they turned out FABULOUS! You will absolutely not regret trying this recipe. And a good chocolate glaze never hurts! YUM! Bon Apetit!
Feb 5, 2012
r1cash Member since: February 5, 2012 REVIEW: I used this recipe, my starter is mature and fed before I started. My starter was foamy and about as thick as thick pancake batter, kinda hard to measure because it was so thick. I made a big batch after the first raise " I allowed two hours for the first raise" I split the dough in half, then made doughnuts and cinnamon rolls. "on the second raise I allowed two hours" now they were not the tallest desert on the table, but they were the first to go.The flavor the tender flakey texture of the Roll and the doughnut were perfect. The fermentation of the dough was perfect leaving an empty plate. do not be afraid to cook until golden brown. This is now my secret weapon when my family wants something special. Like always a good active starter is your best friend. I am making these again soon
Oct 15, 2009
ladylavenderblue Member since: October 15, 2009 REVIEW: I tried this recipe using a sourdough starter I had made that had been fermenting for 7 days. I wasn't sure how the sourdough was going to turn out in this recipe because it had a pancake like batter as compared to other recipes that said the sourdough should be foamy and bubbly which I did not have. It turned out really good. The inside of the dough resembled a flaky, airy texture. I had tried two other sourdough doughnut recipes that was a little bit too heavy.